Fine Fellows Creamery

Fine Fellows Creamery is a locally-owned ice cream shop located at 313 Beach Ave in Cape May, New Jersey, established in 2015. The shop blends artistry with creamery, serving premium Bassetts Ice Cream alongside creative offerings like signature Liege Waffles, ’80s-themed sundaes, smoothies, and açaí bowls, with extensive vegan and gluten-free options to accommodate all dietary preferences. Known for its vibrant, colorful decor and welcoming atmosphere, Fine Fellows is run by owner Dustin Piccolo, a fine arts graduate with a background in high-end florals, and is celebrated as a gay-owned business committed to outstanding customer service and community values.